Unbiased Review of 5DmkIII vs D800

I'm a Sony shooter with only a few lenses. I use to shoot Canon during the film days. I tested both the Canon 5D mkIII and the Nikon D800 and here are my results. I tested a 5DmkIII with a 24-70 f2.8 lens and a Nikon D800 (not D800e) with a 24-70 f2.8 lens.

High ISO:
About the same, except D800 has a lot more detail to work with. In Lightroom, I can save a higher percentage of ISO 6400 shots because the D800 has more detail. Canon seems cleaner initially in Lightroom but when the picture fits into a 24" 1920x1080 monitor or a 64" Samsung plasma TV, the Nikon looks a tad cleaner, noise less noticeable. I think the Canon looks cleaner in Lightroom because it is just a smaller picture. But displaying ISO 6400 shots on a monitor or TV, Nikon looks nicer in general. Both cameras at ISO 12,800 look awful and not recoverable in Lightroom. It might look acceptable as a really small pic but why the heck would you buy an expensive camera to display crappy looking pictures?

Frames per second:
Easy winner. Canon can shoot 6 FPS, Nikon 4 FPS. However, in practice I think 4 FPS is pretty good. None of these cameras are really Olympic style sports cameras.

Resolution:
Easy winner. Nikon's RAW files are more detailed, almost 3D like. I can't really explain it other than the pictures look more real. I can crop a photo to 1/3 it's size (12 megapixels) and it still looks stunning. I wonder how much better the D800e version is. I'll have to wait until my friend receives his to find out.

JPEG:
Easy winner. Out of the camera, the Canon JPEGs are phenomenal. The processing done is quite remarkable.

RAW:
Easy winner. If you shoot RAW, Nikon is it. Also there is an issue with the Canon with the color red. I think the color is overblown at times because all the details are loss and not recoverable in Lightroom. Not always but it has happened at least twice. The same photo on the Nikon kept all the details.

Autofocus:
About the same. Canon and Nikon have awesomely quick autofocus and I couldn't determine a difference. The only caveat is that Nikon focuses better in lowlight (without the autofocus assist lamp) and also the Nikon focuses when there is almost no light (with the autofocus assist lamp). Why the heck doesn't Canon include an autofocus assist lamp is beyond me. Also, Nikon's face detection is extremely useful because it focuses right on the eyeballs.

Flash:
Easy winner. Canon doesn't have built in flash. Nikon flash worked surprisingly well.

Dynamic Range:
Easy winner. Nikon knocked it out of the park. I got a lot less blown highlights with shots with white clothing and more realistic blue skys. Also, there is a lot more headroom on both the highlights and shadows on the Nikon when editing in Lightroom. How did Nikon have better shadows and highlights! They have to share some of that technology!

Video:
Suprisingly about the same. I would have thought that Canon's lead in video would maintain. Surprisingly, the Nikon's video was just as awesome as the Canon. Nikon's video has a bit more detail and is definitely a little sharper than the Canon. I didn't test Nikon's uncompressed HDMI out, although it seems to be a useful feature (this is like RAW HDMI output for video). Canon should adopt uncompressed HDMI out also.

Price:
Easy winner. Why anyone (who doesn't already have Nikon or Canon lenses) would buy this Canon for $500 more than the Nikon would need to think twice. I can see why the Nikon is selling so much better than the Canon, at least on Amazon.

Comfort:
Both about the same weight. Both feel nice in the hand. Canon possibly slightly more comfortable if you have bigger hands. Nikon maybe more comfortable with smaller hands. Both are fine though.

USB transfer:
Nikon wins with USB 3.0. Skipping the card reader altogether by just plugging in the camera to the computer is convenient. Also the transfer speed is much much faster than Canon's older USB 2.0. This saves a lot of time.

LCD Screen:
Canon has slightly better screen in direct sunlight (LCD facing up towards the sun). Nikon is better when the LCD is not directly facing the sun. Nikon's screen is crisper and more 3D like.

Weatherproofing:
My last day of shooting was in a light mist/drizzle. I was shooting both cameras again for about 20 minutes when the Canon 5D mkIII developed some fogging inside the viewfinder screen. I could not wipe it away as it seemed to be inside the camera. I could no longer take pictures normally without live view. Nikon didn't have this problem and I continued to shoot the rest of the day with the Nikon in the same wet conditions without issue. I had planned to shoot at least 2 weeks with both cameras so this was definitely a bummer.

Lenses:
Both Canon and Nikon's 24-70 2.8 lenses are great. I would say the Canon 24-70 2.8 is just a tad faster on focus. Nikon is slightly sharper in the corners. Both Nikon and Canon seem to have a very comparable lens assortment (although my wallet won't be happy buying so many new lenses!)

Well, after using both cameras for about a week, I kept the Nikon D800 and returned my (possibly water damaged) Canon 5D mkIII. Both are phenomenal cameras but D800 has definitely outclassed the 5D mkIII in this round. Maybe Canon will come back strong with its next version. It definitely has some catching up to do.

Thanks for reading my review and I'll also post this on the Nikon D800 and Canon 5D mkIII review page. Best of luck to all you photogs and enjoy these phenomenal cameras!

discount Canon PowerShot A650IS 12.1MP Digital Camera with 6x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom best buy Canon PowerShot D10 12.1 MP Waterproof Digital Camera with 3x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 2.5-Inch LCD with Mini Tool Box (fs) save price Canon PowerShot D10 12MP Digital Camera 3508B001 save on Canon PowerShot D20 12.1 MP CMOS Waterproof Digital Camera with 5x Image Stabilized Zoom 28mm Wide-Angle Lens a 3.0-Inch LCD and GPS Tracking (Blue) best price Canon PowerShot D20 Shock & Waterproof GPS Digital Camera with 8GB Card + Case + Tripod + Accessory Kit cheap Canon PowerShot D20 Waterproof Camera Package discount Canon PowerShot ELPH 110 HS 16.1 MP Digital Camera (Green) + Case + Battery + 8GB Card + Mini Tripod + Cared Reader best buy Canon PowerShot ELPH 110 HS Digial Camera - Blue save price Canon PowerShot ELPH 110 HS Digital Camera (Silver) Value Bundle Kit With 8GB Card + Case + Vidpro Accessory Kit save on Canon PowerShot ELPH 310 HS 12.1 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 8x Wide-Angle Optical Zoom Lens and Full 1080p HD Video (Pink) best price Canon PowerShot ELPH 320 HS 16.1 MP Wi-Fi Enabled CMOS Digital Camera with 5x Zoom 24mm Wide-Angle Lens with 1080p Full HD Video and 3.2-Inch Touch Panel LCD (Silver) cheap Canon PowerShot ELPH 320 HS (Black) 16.1 MP Wi-Enabled CMOS Digital Camera Kit with PSC-55 Bag, Canon Stainless Steel Neck Strap & Canon 2 GB SD Card discount Canon PowerShot ELPH 320 HS (Blue) 16.1 MP Wi-Enabled CMOS Digital Camera Kit with PSC-55 Bag, Canon Stainless Steel Neck Strap & Canon 2 GB SD Card best buy Canon PowerShot ELPH 320 HS Digital Camera Kit - Silver - with 16GB SD Memory Card, Camera Case, Cleaning Kit save price Canon PowerShot ELPH 320 HS (Silver) 16.1 MP Wi-Enabled CMOS Digital Camera Kit with PSC-55 Bag, Canon Stainless Steel Neck Strap & Canon 2 GB SD Card save on Canon PowerShot ELPH 510 HS 12.1 MP - Red with Mini Tool Box (fs) best price Canon PowerShot ELPH 510 HS Digital Camera (Black) Value Kit With 8 GB + Torkia Case + Vidpro Accessory Kit cheap Canon PowerShot ELPH 520 HS 10.1 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 12x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom 28mm Wide-Angle Lens and 1080p Full HD Video Recording (Silver) discount Canon PowerShot ELPH 520 HS Digital Camera - Blue best buy Canon PowerShot ELPH 520 HS Red 10.1 MP 12X Zoom Ultra-Slim Digital Camera save price Canon PowerShot ELPH 520 HS Silver 10.1 MP CMOS Digital Camera 12x Zoom 8 GB Bundle save on Canon PowerShot ELPH 530 HS 10.1 MP Wi-Fi Enabled CMOS Digital Camera with 12x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom 28mm Wide-Angle Lens with 1080p Full HD Video and 3.2-Inch Touch Panel LCD (Black) best price Canon Powershot G10 14.7MP Digital Camera with 5x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom cheap Canon PowerShot G11 10MP Digital Camera with 5x Wide Angle Optical Stabilized Zoom and 2.8-inch articulating LCD discount Canon PowerShot G12 10MP Digital Camera with Ultimate Accessory Kit Package Includes 3 Piece HD Filter Kit, 16Gb High Speed Error Free Memory Card, Case, Extra Battery Pack + 1 Hour AC/DC Battery Charger + More best buy Canon Powershot G1 X 14.1 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 4x Wide-Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom Lens Full 1080p HD Video and 3.0-inch Vari-Angle LCD Deluxe Bundle With 4 GB Secure Digital High Capacity (SDHC) Memory Card, Digpro Compact Camera Deluxe... save price Canon PowerShot G1 X Compact Digital Camera with 14.3 Megapixels, 1.5 inch CMOS Image Sensor, 4x Optical Zoom, 3" TFT Color Display - Special Promotional Bundle save on Canon PowerShot G7 10MP Digital Camera with 6x Image-Stabilized Optical Zoom best price Canon PowerShot Rebel T4i 18.0 MP Digital SLR Kit with 18-55mm Lens, 8 GB Eye-Fi Class 6 SDHC Wireless Memory Card, Carrying Case, UV Filter, HDMI to Mini HDMI Cable, Mini Tripod & Lens Cleaning Kit cheap Canon PowerShot S100 12.1 MP Digital Camera (Black) with 16GB Card + Battery + Case + Underwater Housing + Cleaning & Accessory Kit discount Canon PowerShot S100 Black 12.1 MP 5X Zoom Digital Compact Camera (5244B001) best buy Canon PowerShot S100 (Black) Package save price Canon PowerShot S100 Digital Camera (Black) with 16GB Card + Battery + Case + Tripod + HDMI Cable + Accessory Kit save on Canon PowerShot S100 Digital Camera (Silver) with 16GB Card + Battery + Case + Tripod + HDMI Cable + Accessory Kit best price Canon Powershot S90 10MP Wide-angle 3.8x Optical Zoom Digital Camera Bundle w/ 4GB SD Memory, Card Reader, Case and Lens Cleaning Kit cheap Canon PowerShot S95 10 MP Digital Camera with 3.8x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 3.0-Inch LCD discount Canon PowerShot SD1200IS 10 MP Digital Camera with 3x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 2.5-inch LCD (Silver) best buy Canon PowerShot SD1400IS 14.1 MP Digital Camera (Black) + 8GB Accessory Kit save price Canon PowerShot SD3500IS 14.1 MP Digital Camera with 3.5-Inch Touch Panel LCD and 5x Ultra Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom (Pink) save on Canon PowerShot SD3500 IS Digital ELPH Camera (Pink) 4194B001, 14.1 Megapixel, 3.5" Touch Panel LCD, 5x 24-120mm Equivalent UA Zoom Lens, DIGIC 4 Image Processor, 4 GB Memory Card, Digpro Case, and Lens Cleaner best price Canon PowerShot SD4000IS 10 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 3.8x Optical Zoom and f/2.0 Lens (Red) cheap Canon PowerShot SD4000IS/IXY30S/IXUS300HS 10 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 3.8x Optical Zoom and f/2.0 Lens - WHITE discount Canon Powershot SD430 5MP Digital Camera with 3x Optical Zoom (Wi-Fi Capable) best buy Canon PowerShot SD950IS 12.1MP Digital Camera with 3.7x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom Coach Edition save price Canon Powershot SD990IS 14.7MP Digital Camera with 3.7x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom Coach Kit (Silver) save on Canon PowerShot SX130IS 12.1 MP Digital Camera with 12x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom with 3.0-Inch LCD Super Bundle With 16GB SDHC memory card, Card Reader, DigPro Deluxe Camera Case, Camera & LCD Cleaning Kit, Table Tripod, Screen Protec... best price Canon PowerShot SX150 IS 14.1MP Digital Camera - Black with Mini Tool Box (fs) cheap Canon PowerShot SX160 IS 16.0 MP Digital Camera with 16x Wide-Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom with 3.0-Inch LCD (Black) discount Canon PowerShot SX1IS 10 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 20x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 2.8-inch LCD best buy Canon PowerShot SX210IS 14.1 MP Digital Camera with 14x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 3.0-Inch LCD (Gold) save price Canon PowerShot SX230HS 12 MP Digital Camera (Black) + 8GB Accessory Kit save on Canon PowerShot SX230 HS Blue Digital Camera 12 MP CMOS Sensor, 14x 28-392mm Super Telephoto Zoom Lens, 28mm Wide Angle, Built-In GPS. Kit Includes 4 GB Memory Card, Deluxe Carrying Case, and 3pc. Lens Cleaning Kit. best price Canon Powershot SX230 HS Digital Camera (Blue) 12.1MP CMOS Sensor, 14x 28-392mm Super Telephoto Zoom Lens, Built-In GPS, 3" High Resolution LCD Monitor. Kit Includes 8 GB Memory Card, Card Reader, Carrying Case, Mini Tripod, and More. cheap Canon Powershot SX260 HS 12.1 MP CMOS Digital Camera with 20x Image Stabilized Zoom 25mm Wide-Angle Lens and 1080p Full-HD Video (Black) Premiere Bundle Includes Camera , 8 GB Memory Card, Card Reader, Carrying Case, Mini Tripod, and More. discount Canon PowerShot SX260 HS Black 12.1 MP 20X Zoom Digital Camera best buy Canon Powershot SX260 HS (Black) Package save price Canon PowerShot SX260 HS Digital Camera (Black) with 16GB Card + Battery + Case + Flex Tripod + HDMI Cable + Accessory Kit save on Canon Powershot SX260 HS (Red) Package best price Canon Powershot SX40 HS 12.1 Megapixel Digital Camera, Black 5251B001 cheap Canon Powershot SX40 HS 12.1 MP 35X Zoom Digital Compact Camera discount Canon Powershot SX40 HS 12.1MP Digital Camera with 35x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 2.7-inch Vari-Angle Wide LCD Deluxe Bundle With 4 GB Secure Digital High Capacity (SDHC) Memory Card, Digpro Compact Camera Deluxe Carrying Case, and ... best buy Canon PowerShot SX40 HS 35x Digital Camera (Black) with 16GB Card + Case + Flex Tripod + 2x Telephoto & .45x Wide-Angle Lens + Hood + Accessory Kit save price Canon PowerShot SX40 HS + Battery + Travel Charger + Case + 32GB Card + Cleaning kit + Mini Tripod + Card Reader save on Canon PowerShot SX40 HS Digital Camera (Black) with 16GB Card + Case + Battery + Tripod + Telephoto & Wide-Angle Lenses + Accessory Kit best price Canon PowerShot SX500 IS 16.0 MP Digital Camera with 30x Wide-Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 3.0-Inch LCD (Black) cheap Canon PowerShot SX500 IS + NB-6L Battery Pack + Padded Camera Case + LexSpeed 16GB SDHC Class 10 Memory Card + Card Reader + Flexpod + Cleaning Kit discount Canon PowerShot TX1 7.1MP Digital Camera with 10x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom best buy Canon Rebel T2i 18 MP Body (Broken Kit Box) w/ Supplied Manufacturer Accessories + 3 years Celltime warranty! save price Canon Rebel T2i 18 MP Digital SLR Camera with Canon EF-S 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS SLR Lens + Canon EF 75-300mm f/4-5.6 III Telephoto Zoom Lens + 650-1300mm Super Telephoto Lens+ T-Mount 2x Lens + .40 Super Wide Angle Figheye Lens + 8 Gig Memory Card + Camera. save on Canon Rebel T3 12.2 MP Body (Broken Kit Box) w/ Supplied Manufacturer Accessories best price Canon Rebel T3 12.2 MP CMOS Digital SLR Camera with EF-S 18-55mm IS II Lens Kit + Canon EF 75-300mm III Telephoto Zoom Lens + LEXSpeed 32GB SDHC Class10 Memory Card + LPE10 Spare Battery + Multi-Coated Essential UV Filter + Sunpak 6600DX Digital Tripod... cheap Canon Rebel T3i 18 MP Body (Broken Kit Box) w/ Supplied Manufacturer Accessories + 3 Year Celltime Warranty!! discount Canon Rebel T3i 18.0 MP Digital SLR Kit with 18-55mm Lens, 8 GB Eye-Fi Class 6 SDHC Wireless Memory Card, Carrying Case, UV Filter, HDMI to Mini HDMI Cable, Mini Tripod & Lens Cleaning Kit best buy Canon Rebel T3i (EOS 600D/KISS X5) 10 Lens Deluxe Kit with EF-S 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS II Zoom Lens & EF 75-300mm f/4-5.6 III Telephoto Zoom Lens + 500 Telephoto Preset Lens + Canon 50mm 1.8 Lens + 16GB Deluxe Accessory Kit + 3 Year Celltime Warranty save price Canon Rebel XS 10.1MP Digital SLR Camera with EF-S 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS Lens (Black) save on Canon S100 12.1 MP Digital Camera with 5x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom (Silver) + Digital Led Video Light + Professional Right Angle Bracket + International Travel Charger + NB-5L Battery Pack + Padded Camera Case + LexSpeed 32GB SDHC Class... best price Canon Speedlite 320EX Flash with LED Light with Softbox + Bounce Reflector + (4) Batteries & Charger + Accessory Kit for EOS 7D, 5D, 60D, 50D, Rebel T3, T3i, T2i, T1i, XS Digital SLR Cameras cheap Canon Speedlite 430EX II Flash with Softbox + Bounce Diffuser + (4) Batteries & Charger + Tripod + Accesory Kit for EOS 60D, 7D, 1D X, 1D, 1DS, 5D Mark II III, Rebel T4i, T3i, T3 Digital SLR Camera discount Canon SX30IS 14.1MP Digital Camera with 35x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 2.7 Inch Wide LCD best buy Canon SX40 HS 12.1MP Digital Camera with 35x Wide Angle Optical Image Stabilized Zoom and 2.7-Inch Vari-Angle Wide LCD save price Canon T1i 15.1 MP CMOS Digital SLR Camera with 3-Inch LCD and EF-S 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 IS Lens + Canon LP-E5 Equivalent Replacement Battery (2Pcs) + 16GB SDHC Memory (2Pcs)+ Deluxe Case + Aluminum Tripod + HDMI Cable save on Canon Telephoto EF 300mm f/4.0L IS Image Stabilizer USM Autofocus Lens + Canon Deluxe Lens Case + Lens Pen Cleaning System + Lens Cap Holder + Multi-Coated 3pc Essential Filter Kit + Giotto's Super Rocket Air Blower + Micro Fiber Cleaning Cloth best price Casio EX-FC150 10.1MP High Speed Digital Camera with 5x Zoom with CMOS Shift Image Stabilization and 2.7 inch LCD (Red) cheap Casio EX-FH100 10.1MP High Speed Digital Camera with 10x Ultra Wide Angle Zoom with CMOS Shift Image Stabilization and 3.0 inch LCD discount Casio EX-FH25 10.1MP High Speed Digital Camera with 20x Wide Angle Zoom with CMOS Shift Image Stabilization and 3.0 inch LCD best buy Casio Exilim EX-F1 6MP 12x Zoom 2.8-Inch LCD Pro Digital Camera with CMOS Shift Image Stabilization (Black) save price CASIO EXILIM EX-FC200S Red EX-FC200SRD save on Casio Exilim Ex-fh100 High Speed Camera Silver best price Casio Exilim EX-FH20 9.1 MP Digital Camera with 20x Optical Zoom and 3-Inch LCD (Black) cheap Casio Exilim EX-FH20 9.1MP Digital Camera 20x Optical Zoom 1000 FPS discount Casio EXILIM EX-H15 Digital Point & Shoot Camera best buy Casio Exilim EX-Z1050 10.1MP Digital Camera with 3x Anti Shake Optical Zoom (Blue) save price Casio Exilim EX-Z250BK 9MP 4x Zoom 3-Inch LCD Screen Digital Camera with 28mm Wide Angle Lens CCD-shift Image Optical Stabilizer (Black) save on Casio Exilim EX-Z90 12.1MP Digital Camera with 3x Optical Zoom and 2.7 inch TFT LCD (Black) best price Casio Exilim EX-ZR100 12.1 MP CMOS Sensor with 12.5x Optical Zoom Digital Camera Black cheap Casio Exilim Hi-zoom Ex-h20g bk Digital Camera Black discount Casio Exilim Hi-zoom Ex-h20g sr Digital Camera Silver best buy Casio Exilim Pro EX-F1 Digital Camera, 6.0 MP, with 60fps High Speed Burst Mode, Full HD Movies, 12x Optical, 4x Digital Zoom, 2.8" HP LCD Screen save price Casio Exlim EX-Z1200 12MP Digtial Camera with 3x Anti Shake Optical Zoom (Black) save on Casio EX-S200BE 14.1MP Digital Camera with 4x Optical Image Stabilized Zoom with 2.7 inch TFT LCD (Blue)